Our Team

Tim Machtel
Senior Pastor

Rev. Tim Machtel was born in Marshall, Michigan, and moved to southeast Florida at age 12. He grew up in Palm Beach Gardens, where his sister and brother-in-law still reside. Tim’s parents now live with him and his wife, Debbie.

Debbie, originally from Oviedo, Florida, is a graduate of the University of Central Florida and the owner/operator of AR Workshop in the Shady Oaks Shopping Center in Ocala. Her parents and siblings continue to live in Oviedo, Florida. Tim and Debbie have two daughters: Abigail, who lives in Riverview, Florida, with her husband, Rudy—both graduates of the University of Central Florida, and Bekah, who lives in Brandon, Florida.

Tim earned a Bachelor of Arts in Bible and Theology from Asbury College (now Asbury University) in Wilmore, Kentucky, and a Master of Divinity from Asbury Theological Seminary, where he was part of the first graduating class of the Orlando campus. He has also completed the Institute of Preaching, the Reynolds Program for Church Leadership, and is certified in The 6 Types of Working Genius through The Table Group.

He was commissioned as a Provisional Elder in the Florida Conference of The United Methodist Church in May 2003 and ordained as an Elder in Full Connection in June 2006. Tim began his ministry as a student local pastor at Boyd United Methodist Church in Boyd, Kentucky. In the Florida Conference, he has served at Trilby United Methodist Church and Community United Methodist Church in San Antonio as a two-point charge, as Executive Pastor at Beach United Methodist Church in Jacksonville, as Senior Pastor at First United Methodist Church of Dunedin, and as Senior Pastor at St. Andrew’s United Methodist Church in Brandon.

In July 2023, he began his appointment at Ocala First United Methodist Church following a three-year personal leave from the Florida Conference.

 
 
Director of Children and Family Ministries
Mary Pieper
Director Youth Ministries

Mary serves as the Director of Youth Ministry, working with 6th–12th grade students in our church and throughout the Ocala community. A Florida native, she grew up in a ministry family and developed a heart for serving students from an early age. Mary is a graduate of Florida Southern College, where she earned a Bachelor of Arts in Religion with a concentration in Youth Ministry.

She is passionate about building meaningful relationships with young people and walking alongside them as they navigate life’s challenges, helping them grow with a strong, faith-filled foundation. Mary strives to create a welcoming and authentic environment where students feel known, valued, and encouraged in their faith. 

Outside of youth ministry, Mary is most likely playing the flute! She is married to Matt, a trumpet player in the Orlando Philharmonic, and together they enjoy music, coffee, and traveling. They also have an adorable cat named Java Bean who completes their family!
David Bedenbaugh
Director of Music

David leads the Praise Band at the 9:00 a.m. service and directs the choir at the 11:00 a.m. service, while also overseeing the church’s tech ministry. A native of Central Florida, he grew up in DeLand and relocated to Ocala in 2011 from Nashville, Tennessee.

He holds a Bachelor of Music in Piano Performance from Stetson University and a Master of Music in Composition from Belmont University. David is an independent contemporary Christian recording artist, as well as a composer and arranger of art songs, choral anthems, and orchestral works. He plays both piano and guitar, and in his free time, he enjoys playing tennis.

David is married to Cheri, a nurse practitioner. Together, they enjoy spending time at the beach and traveling when they can. They share their home with their cavachon dog, Kushbi, and their son, Bodie.

Elaine McCreary
Organist / HAndbell Director

Elaine Wellhoner McCreary is a seventh-generation native of Marion County. According to family history, two of her great-great-great grandfathers helped build Ocala’s first Methodist church around 1850.

She graduated from Ocala High School in 1966 and went on to attend Florida State University, where she earned a Bachelor’s degree in Music Education (1970) and master’s degrees in Educational Leadership (1979) and Library and Information Systems (2002). Elaine later served on the faculty at Florida A&M University as an academic librarian and head of Interlibrary Loan.

After retiring in 2018, she returned home to Marion County. Elaine is married to Rev. Ron McCreary, and they have one daughter and three grandsons. She has served as an organist in several Florida churches and has many years of experience ringing and directing handbells.

Bobbi Deriso
Director of Ocala First Preschool

Bobbi Deriso is a lifelong resident of Marion County. She earned her Bachelor of Arts in Elementary Education from Saint Leo University and spent 12 years teaching at the elementary level—aside from a brief year in middle school, after which she quickly returned to her passion for younger students.

In November 2012, she followed God’s calling to serve as Director of Preschool Ministries at FUMC. Bobbi married Brian Deriso, a high school chemistry teacher, in 2009, and together they share a blended family of five children: Ashton, Coralei, William, Liam, and Madigan—“yours, mine, and ours.”

In her free time, Bobbi enjoys reading, going to the movies, and spending time with family and friends. Alongside a dedicated team of preschool staff, she is committed to OFP’s mission of being kind, being helpful, and sharing God’s love with others.

 
Judie Coe-Wirth
Finance and Business Manager
Jessica Adams
Communication Coordinator
Colton Singletary
Director of Production
Vicente Lugo
Maintenance Manager
Daryl Smith
Maintenance and custodial care